Dryer balls review
What are dryer balls? Do dryer balls really work?
A few months ago I added a product link to dryer balls on my Energy efficient dryers page. I had seen these dryer balls listed by several merchants whose products I offer, and each merchant mentioned an 'independent study' showing that the dryer balls cut the energy used to dry laundry by up to 25%.
Dryer balls are air-filled rubber or plastic balls covered in bumps, which you toss into your dryer along with a load of laundry. In theory, these balls fluff your garments more during tumbling, which softens clothes, and keeps them from clinging together, so that more air exchange occurs between the clothes, leading to faster drying times.
That's the theory, anyways. I should have been more skeptical. I once spent $80 on a set of plastic laundry discs that were supposed to make laundry detergent obsolete. My friends and I were convinced these discs saved on detergent, reduced water pollution, eliminated unwanted detergent smells from our laundry, and did as good a job cleaning clothes as Tide.
But eventually we noticed that our clothes were getting grayer and grayer, which is what would have happened if we had washed our clothes in plain water. I later heard that a Consumers Reports study found no difference between washing with laundry discs, and washing just in water. But they're still for sale all over the place.
Challenged by a visitor
Dryer balls from Gaiam
No longer for sale on my site
Given my past experience with laundry discs, I should probably have done a dryer balls review before posting the product on my website. I don't want site visitors to buy something through me that doesn't actually save them energy.
A couple of weeks ago I received an e-mail from Svein Medhus, who had found my quote about independent testing of these dryer balls. Svein asked me for evidence of the claim. I went looking for confirmation of the "25% reduction in drying time" statement, and found that hundreds of websites sell this product and quote the claims, but no site provided the independent test results.
So I fired off an e-mail to Nellie's All Natural, who are the distributor of Nellie's Dryer Balls, the product I featured. Within a day I got back a Microsoft Word document containing the test results.
The independent test report
Dryer balls test report
The test document states that no part of it may be reproduced unless the entire report is reproduced in full, so I won't quote it, but can send it to anyone who wants a copy, and I can paraphrase conclusions and measurements within the report. Here are some interesting points:
- The report is in MS Word format, a modifiable format. While I don't believe anyone would tamper with the original report conclusions, we can't exclude the possibility that the report has been modified to improve the case for these dryer balls.
- The report is not signed by an individual. The report is dated, but there are two dates: Date of this report: 12-Jul-04, and Date testing completed: 19-Jul-04. Odd that the report was written before testing was completed!
- The report was produced by Technicare Services Limited of Leicester UK, if anyone wants to contact them and ask for more details.
- The report concludes that drying rate is 15% to 25% faster compared to no dryer balls, when drying clothes to a given humidity level.
- The report shows a table with 'Percentage increase over dry conditioned weight' at starting time, and 15/30/45/60 minute intervals.
After reading Svein's challenge to the report, and looking at the timed results more closely, I agree with him that there is a problem reconciling the data with the testing company's conclusions. Let's look at a chart showing percentage increase over dry conditioned weight for the four loads tested (two with, two without dryer balls). I've rebaselined this so that the Y axis denotes percentage of dry weight, instead of weight increase; so the 160 line means the laundry at that point would have weighed 160% of dry weight, or 60% more than dry weight.
Dryer balls test results chart
As you can see, the two loads that used dryer balls definitely had a bit of an advantage in terms of having a lower total weight through most of the drying cycle. But can we really conclude a 25% speed-up in drying time? From the graph, it looks like the runs with dryer balls made it to the finish line by the 45 minute mark, while those without dryer balls didn't make it until the 60 minute mark, which seems to support the theory that the dryer balls shortened drying time by 15 minutes or 25%.
Except that we really don't know when, between the 45- and 60-minute marks, each load achieved 100% of starting dry weight, because the loads were only weighed every 15 minutes. Suppose we tried to smooth out the chart lines on 5 minute intervals, predicting each unknown 5 minute interval so that the overall line from previous points stays smooth. Then our chart would look more like this:
Drying rate with and without dryer balls after smoothening
Notice the vertical section at the bottom of each line, which suggests when we can reasonably expect each load to have reached 100% dry. As you can see, the loads with balls probably reached 100% of original dry weight (i.e. dry) around 43:30 minutes and 45:00 minutes after start, while the loads without dryer balls probably reached dry state around 48:00 minutes and 50:00 minutes respectively. If we average each pair of runs we get:
49m00s / 44m15s = 49.00 / 44.25 = 1.107.
In other words, while the loads with dryer balls did dry faster, they only dried about 10.7% faster - nowhere near the 15-25% claimed in the report or the 'up to 25%' claimed by the company selling these dryer balls. And with only four runs total, it's hard to draw any statistically significant conclusion from such a narrow gap between the runs with and without dryer balls.
Admittedly, my guess at when they did become 100% dry is speculation - but it's clear that the original tests simply don't support the conclusion of a 25% or even a 15% reduction in drying time. The test report even includes a statement that the improvement in drying time is 'not significant' but is 'real'. We can at least agree with the 'not significant' part of the conclusion.
After he had reviewed the test report, Svein decided to do a test of his own, with a set of dryer balls he bought from a different company.
He ran four tests, as with the original, independent tests. He used a typical laundry load consisting of socks, underwear, t-shirts, towels, jeans, pants and a shirt. In each test he washed the laundry in a front loading washer and ran it at a spin speed of 1500 RPM to extract most of the laundry water.
Svein weighed the laundry items at the start and end of the drying cycle, and used an electricity meter similar to the Kill A Watt meter to measure kilowatt hours used by his electric condensing dryer (a dryer that uses a heat exchanger and water to condense moisture out of the air in the dryer). Here are Svein's results:
|No dryer balls||Dryer balls|
|Run 1||Run 2||Average||Run 1||Run 2||Average|
|Wet weight (g)||4296||4220||4258||4230||4210||4220|
|Dry weight (g)||2926||2948||2937||2950||2950||2950|
|Kwh per liter water removed||1.35||1.29||1.32||1.31||1.31||1.31|
From the averages, you can see that the drying time without dryer balls was actually faster than that with dryer balls, while the amount of energy used per liter of water extracted was virtually identical.
So, are dryer balls worth the money?
Does it really make sense to buy dryer balls? Do they work? Will they really save you energy or money? Here are some things to consider:
- The claim that 'independent testing' has confirmed up to 25% reduction in drying time isn't supported by the evidence the report provides. This may be why the 'independent testing' isn't linked to from any site I found that sells these products and sports the claims.
- Svein's results show no significant difference in drying time and energy used between runs with and without dryer balls
- The independent tests did identify some increase in softness and a reduction in lint production, which may be another reason some people like these dryer balls.
- Consumers who have bought these dryer balls report a range of reactions, from early breakage, to no noticeable difference in dryer time, to people raving about how much energy the dryer balls save.
There are also some differences between Svein's tests and those done by Technicare Services:
- Svein used a condensing dryer, which works differently from the standard tumble dryers used in the test. It's possible that the dryer balls may have a different effect on drying time or energy use in a regular air-venting dryer.
- Svein used dryer balls from a different manufacturer. It is possible that Nellie's Dryer Balls do actually reduce drying time more than the dryer balls Svein bought, although we must remember even Technicare admitted that the improvement was not significant.
- Svein used mostly 100% cotton laundry. The Technicare tests used mostly polyester fabrics, which doesn't seem like a typical fiber mix for the 21st century.
Again, if you really want to save money and energy on laundry, the best place to start is with an energy saving washer that washes your clothes with less energy, and extracts more of the water during the spin cycle, and then to use a clothes line or clothes rack, or make sure you have an energy efficient dryer to dry your clothes.
Why do so many sites promote dryer balls
Remember that, once someone has bought a product, unless they are unhappy with it, they tend to sing its praises to reassure themselves that they've made a good purchase. That's what my friends and I did with our laundry discs, and it may be what's behind many of the positive reviews of this product elsewhere.
Also, the sites that promote these dryer balls are just trying to earn a commission on their sale. There's nothing wrong with websites earning commissions from product sales - if websites like mine didn't earn money on product sales and advertising, we wouldn't be able to operate. But webmasters do have a responsibility to make sure they're not selling false hopes or products that don't live up to their claims, which is why I've removed the dryer balls for sale from my site, and instead written this dryer balls review.
Svein has written his own review, dryer balls save no energy, on his blog, which is called The Urge for Less Energy Use.
Roselyn, 7/28/2010: I just wanted to relate my experience with dryer balls. I have stopped using softener since I already have softened water. I started using the dryer balls a month ago and I have seen a noticeable difference in my clothing in the form of less wrinkles and greater softness. My husband has also commented that his underwear feels softer. So whether or not they save energy, they do save money in eliminating softener and time by having less ironing.
Mary, 11/7/2010: I like my dryer balls. They seem to work and are certainly less expensive than buying dryer sheets. Also I'm allergic to many, many additives so these are great for me. One problem I have is that in my large front loading laudromat dryers, the balls make the door locks pop. In the smaller laundromat dryers, they work fine.
Diane, 1/3/2011: You don't need dryer balls, just throw in a pair of old tennis shoes. Less wrinkles, fluffier towels, and a way to recycle your old sneakers. Not sure about taking less time to dry clothes. But we partially dry our clothes to get wrinkles out then hang on rack to dry(indoors, to avoid pollen). Last night I used pair of old tennis shoes and reduced dryer time in half since it didn't take long to get out wrinkles. They may have been a little wetter, so some clothes may take longer to air dry, but they were almost dry this morning. Thanks for info, very helpful. I also want to check some news station sites, for independent testing. When those laundry disks first came out a few years ago, one of the news stations tested them and came to same conclusion you did.
Ezra, 1/22/2011: I saw the advertisement at a time I was wearing identical type work clothes daily. Saturday was my wash day. Identical size load month after month. My first wash load went into the electric dryer and the second load into the washer. I had to wait for the dryer to finish to place the second load in to dry. I do not remember the length of time but when I first used the dryer balls the dryer was finished after the second load of wash was out of the washer. When I calculated the difference in time , it was better than 30% saving.
When I first saw the ad. I knew it had to make an improvement but I did not expect that much. Anything that will make a pathway for airflow between the laundry allows for faster removal of the moisture. Very elementary. I should have thought of that years before.
One more thing. I have found tennis balls do almost as well and may cost less. The more balls, the better the circulation. If you need to use a dryer, don't forget the balls. It will seve you a lot of money. You can prove it for yourself.
Brenda, 2/19/2011: love my dryer balls that I've used for about three months. But after two months the stuffing came out. I replaced it with some home sponges. Now the green plastic has started to crack up. Do I have any choice except buy more which I doubt I will.
Joan, 4/9/2011: I have been using dryer balls for about eight years, ever since a fabric softener spill at a container terminal in Halifax, NS. When the clean-up crew had to wear hazmat suits, I felt it was time to check out fabric softeners! They are the cause behind many skin problems, i.e. itching and allergies. I love my dryer balls. Energy savings are just an added benefit.
David, 5/19/2012: The UK Consumer Association investigated these balls and reported in August 2010 that they lead to slightly longer drying times on a full load, and gave no benefits with respect to softness or wrinkles.
If you have comments about this page please contact us. We are happy to post comments we feel will be helpful to other site visitors. Don't forget that people being happy with their dryer balls doesn't mean they actually save energy. I used a plastic laundry disk for over a year and swore by it - a teaspoon of detergent was all I needed, although our laundry did come out a bit grey. Turns out you can get exactly the same result with a teaspoon of detergent without the overpriced laundry disks! It would be great to hear from others who have actually measured the effectiveness (or lack thereof) of their dryer balls.